In A Silent Way

Jazzy

Hmmmm, guess it was better than some of the others

Reckon this would have gone down a treat in the background when I was at uni getting stoned. Still pleasant, though the high hat 16s are irritating after a while. Miles' tone is always lovely.

джаз как джаз kind of blue у него лучше звучит а под этот альбом я сидел делал домашку, поэтому не вслушивался мб для этого он и создан, так как эти две песни не отвлекали меня крч 3/5

Chill Jazz vibes. It's aight.

There are better Mile Davis albums

Bien.

Van has never referenced Miles Davies as an influence (they were more contemporaries anyway) but the similarities between the opening of 'in a silent way' and Van's 'haunts of ancient peace' are marked. I'm not accusing Van of plagiarism by any means as Van was able to build upon this beautiful ambient sound and craft one of his greatest recordings whereas Miles' jazzy leanings in the middle of his song are less interesting to me.

Rustig, trekt een beetje op 'No Drum and Bass in the Jazz Room' van Clever Girl.

Jazz isn't my thing, but I do love the sound Miles got from his horn. Side one belongs to that omnipresent fizzing from the hi-hat and some of the coolest bass I've ever heard. I heard someone use the word "ambient" to describe the album. It is something you'd put on late at night while peacefully discussing with a couple of friends.

Im not a jazz guy but this actually good

Hyvin toimi matkalla mökille. Mukavia maileja Milesin kaa!

Not his best but still decent.

Nice jazz album from miles Davis. Not a lot of songs but it’s 40 minutes of nice flowing, easy listening jazz. It’s pretty good. 7.0/10

Got lost in the background and like 30 mins later it was still going. Pretty relaxing

Plays constantly in my mind like a cocaine fuelled orgy with my parents and their good friends Jeff and Margaret. They sometimes dress up as farm yard animals. Jeff has enormous testicle. Margaret has a bucket cunt. It all makes for a rather good time.

I wish I liked jazz but I just don't.

The birth of FUSION. Wasn't a huge fan but loved this from the Wikipedia page "Rock critics thought In a Silent Way sounded like rock, or at least thought Miles was nodding in their direction, and practically wet themselves with joy. Jazz critics, especially ones who didn't listen to much rock, thought it sounded like rock too, and they reacted less favorably"

Onthouden voor een romantisch diner, niet geschikt voor werk klussen.

Enjoyable to a point, but the majority album made me feel very stressed, as though I was on the verge of a panic attack and that feeling felt like an eternity before letting up in the last few minutes. It evoked a journey in my mind but not one I'm interested in revisiting.

It all sounds very similar. It was very easy listening while eating dinner and would make a nice environment if people were over. Wish I could give it a 3.5/5

After listening to four of his albums, I think I've learned that Miles Davis is the king of cracking a note and then cracking it again when the phrase is repeated so it sounds like the first one was on purpose. If my songs were 20 minutes long, I wouldn't want to do extra takes, either. Best track: Shhh / Peaceful

Oké album, maar niet speciaal

Nice jazz

You're led to believe that Miles Davis is a genius, the primal exponent of a musical form and the template for a generation of artists to follow. But I must be missing something, as this felt like the B-side of the soundtrack to a forgettable Steve McQueen film. 38 minutes felt like much longer, and not in a good way.

Druga pozycja Davisowa na liscie, ale tym o wiele bardziej eksperymentalna, bo jest to fusion jazz oparty w duzej mierze na dzwiekach eleltrykowych, zarowno klawiszy, pan hancock, jak i gitarek, ale nie mozna takze odmowic niczego saksie pana Shorter jak i kunsztowi z jakim posluguje sie trabka pan Davis, ktorego nadal jest mi malo na tym nagraniu, 40 minutowy album dzieli sie na dwie czesci shhh/pacefull i tytulowy in a silent way, oba prawie dwudziestominutowe utwory sa podzielone na trzy czesci, co czuc zwlaszcza na tytulowym traku, natomiast shh ma bardziej jednolita kompozycje i subtleniejsze przejscia, wlasnie ta plyta rozpoczyna Milesowa elektryczna epoke, dzieki czemu stal sie niewatpliwa sila sprawcza rowniez w muzyce rozrywkowej, bo brzmienie fusion jazzu ktorego tutaj jest pionierem przewija sie zarowno przez funk, blues, a nawet r&b, ale jak dla mnie jest to plyta na ktorej za malo jest Milesa w Davisie, nagraniu brakuje jakiejs ekspresyjnosci, nie chodzi tu nawet o to ze jak cos jest zbyt perfekcyjnie zagrane, to brzmi to jak cos dopieszczonego przez producenta i bedacego owocem intensywnego overdubowania, ale jakos nie trafia do mnie motyw in a silent way ktory jest grany bardziej na modle rokowa niz jazzowa, no ale jesli stoisz w miejscu, to tak jakbys sie cofal, jesli wszystko inne idzie do przodu, tak samo jest z muzyka, wiec taka zmiana brzmienia jest calkiem zrozumiala, ale jednoczesnie nie jestem jej fanem, na plejke juz nic nie dodam, bo tytulowy in a silent way juz na niej jest, bo nie jest to moje pierwsze spotkanie z tym albumem, a czuje ze pan Davis jeszcze przynajmniej raz sie pojawi na liscie

29. In a Silent Way - Miles Davis 2 tracks, (but 18 & 19 mins each). This is exactly why I'm doing @1001_albums_gen . Just Miles, his trumpet & some backing snare drum & keyboard. Really unusual/interesting & not something I would normally listen to at all. The use of the snare drum is brilliant and forms the basis for everything else to come and go as it pleases. It has a sort of hypnotic quality. 3/5

Ok 2 sange? Til gengæld lange... Mere som en Jam session. Elsker Miles, men det her bliver lige lovligt langt i spytter

Chillade i bakgrunden medans essäer skrevs

Jazz... Nice

Jazzy noir, like stumbling out of a bar in a neon-covered part of the city, fighting your way through there rain to the next bar.

What more can you ask for

I generally am not a fan of jazz albums. I feel like I don't have the necessary expertise to fully enjoy them, and as a result, I don't like the music. However, this one is an exception. I enjoyed it as it was lively when it needed to be and soothing when it wanted to be. My only gripe is that each song is just a bit long. Favorite track: In a Silent Way

Odotukset oli korkeammalla, olisin toivonut tykkääväni enemmän, mutta ei tämä sitten sen enempää fiiliksiä herättänyt. Mielestäni aika geneeristä jatsia, tiluttelua ja sen semmoista.

Rating: 6/10

3 stars for the massive influence, but definitely not the enjoyment factor

It sure is Miles Davis. I'm no jazz aficionado but most jazz sounds kinda similar to me (although I'm sure Miles Davis produces some of the best of it)

long sax songs lol

Tyckte om albumet. Gillar verkligen Miles Davis men det här är inte mitt favoritprojekt av honom. Inte exakt den jazzen jag gillar. Endast två låtar som är på 20 min vilket inte jag gillar. 3/5

This was a really interesting listen. I wasn't sure what to expect, and it's probably good I didn't have solid expectations because this album is all over the place. I liked it. I’m giving it 3 stars instead of 4 because I didn’t love all of it but I’d definitely listen to more Miles Davis in the future.

Maybe it's because I listened to it while studying and I've been listening to a lot of instrumentals, but it didn't really click for me

Nice progression across just two long tracks. Nice listen and great to relax, think, work.

More up pace jazz

Mellow and contemplative.

Good for what it is, not something I would listen to again

Only 2 'songs'! I liked it, though I'm not sure I understand it all...

Vielleicht waren meine Erwartungen gedämpft, nach dem Max seinem Kommentar. Aber ich fand es gar nicht Mal so schlecht! Krasse Soli und doch so gechillt!

Gute Hintergrundmusik, überraschenderweise nicht wirklich viel mehr.

Miles Davis is a name you’ve heard many times before but have not necessarily listened to his music. Like me, you probably knew he played a saxophone...or was it a trumpet? And that he is also a jazz musician. I must admit I did not know anymore than this before listening to this album. My mind was even more curious after discovering there are only two tracks listed on the lp. I can say this though...without coming anywhere remotely close to being an aficionado of jazz or classic instrumental music, I certainly can appreciate the ability and dedication needed to play an instrument at such a level even an outsider and self confessed non-lover of the genre finds it more than enjoyable and even moving in an emotional sense. Do yourself a favour...if you haven’t already. 3 Stars

3/5 nice jazz sounds, but not special.

Va?! Det är ju bara två låtar wth Långa tho... Helt ok, hade gett 3,5 men men

Jazzy but not a huge fan, very slow

some of these long tracks just make you lose track of time. not frenetic jazz like a few newer releases from Miles Davis.

nice jazz but the piano was a it too discordant which set me on edge so not a fully enjoyable listen for me

5

Como para estar en la playa con un mojito bien cargado

Fine for background listening but i can't give it more than a three tbh

Too mindful for me

Jazz. Simplemente agradable. Dos temas de 15 min cada uno.

Classy music to work by

Jazzy. Very moody

A true classic, I actually discovered this album through Bill Laswell's "Panthalassa" reworks. Then I went straight to the source. It brings back some memories of good old days.

dont know much about jazz but enjoyed this especially as background music while working

First impressions: A lot more organ and guitar than I've ever heard in a jazz album. Seemingly the beginnings of jazz "fusion". Not my favorite Miles Davis. His trumpet sounds harsher and can be downright annoying at times. Never felt this way in Kind of Blue.

I'm on board. An interesting listen that i will probably go back to.

2 long Jazz songs that made nice background music

2 songs 38 minutes? king behavior

Not bad. Would listen again if it was on.

I don't think I have the ability to appreciate jazz enough and listening to this I can begin to but I still struggle to find differences in this compared to other jazz. Hopefully I will get more jazz albums that I will be able to start learning more about jazz.

Totally fine. Kind of Blue is definitely a better Miles Davis album

First time I’ve actually listened to Miles Davis even though I’ve heard his name referenced for so long on the Simpson’s!

Intricate blend of bluesy piano, saxophone, and guitar create a wonderfully jazzy soundscape however music and sound a little frustrating at times.

Surprised when the album ended after two songs. Nice to listen to while working but wouldn't choose this over others.

Not my normal listening but quite enjoyed it.

It was good, but not what I look for in Jazz. Not super chill, and not super funky, so I don't know when would be the best time to listen to it.

I didn't like this album as much as kind of blue. Miles Davis is still one of the best when it comes to trumpet and cool jazz.

Ubeat/chill mix across both tracks, guitar-y for Miles Davis. Ironside incidental music. Good for Liverpool->Southport train. 6/10

lombrado ne dificil

Well jazz is definitely not my thing. I have no idea where to start even comprehending what I heard. I mean, it probably is technically pure genius and all that other jazz (LOL), but I'm just too incompetent to understand it.

Pleasant enough, didn’t make me angry or anxious which can sometimes happen with jazz.

Another jazz album that's correct background music.

The album is exactly what I think of when I hear 'Jazz'. In that regard, I think that is a good thing. On the other hand, it wasn't terribly exciting.

Jazz fusion, jazz with electric instrumentation and back beat. Good background music.

jazz not really my thing but this is quite intersting at times and easy to listen to

Silent and chill

Modern Jazz is just too exciting for me to really get into this. I respect the talent tho

Im not a good Jazz listener :-/

I really didn't think this was that good. Miles Davis is a legend and there is other material of his that I like. This I found to be a slog, mainly because of the repetitiveness of the two tracks. This was just devoid of anything interesting or truly risky. 2 stars.

Je n’avais jamais écouté de jazz et j’ai réussi à apprécier, probablement parce que c’était le bon moment avec la bonne vibe. Mais j’ai toujours l’impression que ces chansons sont improvisées et faites de notes aléatoires, donc j’ai du mal à trouver une mélodie et une harmonie.

I didn't really enjoy In a Silent Way. The long tracks, heavy emphasis on improvisation, and lack of clear direction just didn't click with me. I can appreciate what Miles Davis was trying to achieve, and listening to this album made me want to explore more of his work. That led me to Kind of Blue, which I found far more engaging and much easier to connect with. I'm not much of a jazz enthusiast, so that certainly influenced my experience. While this album gave me a greater appreciation for Miles Davis as an artist and his impact on music, the album itself simply didn't resonate with me.

Ok

There's worse jazz on this list. But I still don't get it at all.

Not a jazz fan, but ok for background noise.

I'm not a jazz fan, but I'm always willing to give it a play! IThis may be an important jazz album, but it leaves me a bit bored.

Perfectly fine for household chores listening.

All these MD albums and I still haven’t found one that really blew me away. Track 1 is repetitive and boring though I did enjoy the softness in track 2. But in reality, meh? I couldn’t play this at a themed party cause the songs go on too long the guests would get antsy

Klingt gut und ist atmosphärisch aber geht irgendwie nirgendwo hin. Leider kein Vergleich mit Kind of Blue

This was only two tracks unlike the extended play which is awesome

I was really disappointed with this one. Kind of Blue is one of my favourites of all time, so I was really excited for this. I just found it kind of boring to be honest.

4/10 Clearly talented, clearly important, not my type of music.

Oh, it's just two long songs. And the music I started liking was after the album was over. At least it's better than Bitches Brew.

I'll be the first to admit I don't really know anything about Jazz. But I had listened to and enjoyed certain stuff, but this album didn't really make me feel anything. It never really seemed to get going, and as soon as I thought it was going too it changed back. Nothing bad, but nothing really memorable. 2.5* rounded to 2*

Not sure I have the taste level required to appreciate something like this. Felt like I was in the lobby bar of a very swish hotel from decades ago. Not entirely sure how it sets itself above anything else in this same genre. It wasn’t bad but it didn’t feel spectacular in any way. This may require a little more deep diving.

Interesting to listen to. Am I ever going to listen to it again? Nope. I just feel like this whole genre is set up to waste good talent under the pretence of 'improvisation'. Just feels like it could be better if they tried harder. I don't know what I'm talking about though.

Kinda weird but not bad. Solid 2.5

For a trumpet player, there wasn't a lot of trumpet on this album. More trumpet, less of everything else, please.

While I have been getting more into Jazz in recent years, I just can't get into Miles Davis. Maybe I'll come around eventually, but it's just not my thing.

En tiedä jazzista mitään mutta kyllähän tätä nyt kuuntelin

Straingh.....

music for a late night club

Miles und ich werden wohl keine großen Freunde mehr...

Pretty easy listening. Preferred towards the end of the second track where it gets more interesting

Fue una buena experiencia, pero tampoco soy el mayor fan de jazz

jazz full isntrumental dos canciones de 30 min c/u, no me termino de cerrar 2/5

I like the flow of this record but overall the sound itself isn’t my favorite. I really tried to like this more but it’s just not for me

What an album to sleep to holy moly

I really don't want to be someone who just rules albums out by genre immediately so I swear I try to listen to everything with an open mind. But jazz continues to be outside of my understanding. I enjoyed the first song for a little while from about 6 minutes in and I liked the first and last four minutes of the second song. But both are 20 minute long songs with big sections of what sounds to me to be unstructured freestyle saxophone that drove me a little mad so I'll probably never listen to the bits I did like again. Favourite song: In a Silent Way Least: Shhh / Peaceful

liked it better than a love supreme

Liked the trumpet parts and it surely is intriguing music if you like jazz. But apparently it was recorded on one day and I think to hear that fact.

Monotonous, i would have love some trumpet melody improvisation along all track.

i had a good time listening but like 10 minutes after the fact i couldn't recall a single individual moment from the entire record. if i got strapped to a clockwork orange machine and forced to just listen and not think about anything else as i stared through unblinking eyes at a bass visualizer for about 40 minutes, i would probably walk away thinking "this is good and cool and important" but as it is im just not that guy. my favorite song was technically It's About That Time

First half is pretty cool, consisting of jazz that scratches my brain and keeps me involved. The second half shuts down my brain's processes, lulling me into a shallow musical coma. Time slows, the tempo is unabating, the trumpet keeps on barking, and I keep searching for the brew (unsuccessfully). Enough about me, I want to see what the jazz enthusiast has to say about this one 4.6/10

3.4/10

jazz sounds

Pas fan de Miles Davis

v chill. would be fun to see as a live performance!

no issues with this really, just not for me

I like a bit of Miles, and this was pushing boundaries - lots of electric guitar, electric piano and drums that borrow a little from the rock world. Unfortunately the pieces sound like improvised noodling with little musical structure to my untrained ears, "like a goat shitting into a tin bucket" as an old lady once said in response to hearing experimental jazz. I wouldn't listen to this actively again, but it's pleasant background listening.

I appreciate that Miles Davis is regarded as a genius, but Jazz is about the only genre I can’t ever relate to.

Sleepy

ok

Nice

Unlike most jazz this actually had a few redeeming qualities, mainly a tight band that could probably do some cool stuff in other contexts. Still no actualy songs, though; just noodling, which has interesting bits intermittently.

Chill jazz. Neither good nor bad. I'm not really into instrumental jazz. Cool album cover though.

Not bad but confirm that jazz is not really my thing. I can see why people like it though.

1.5

I can really see what this album is going for, and I can understand the appeal of jazz. However, it really isn't for me. The musicians are all very talented, but it just meanders and wanders about for 40 minutes without ever feeling like it's going anywhere.

Yeah this is really not my vibe at all. I appreciate the talent needed to make this music, but no thanks. Never liked trombones much.

Clearly this isn't for me

This is the type of jazz that turns the average listener away from this genre. Unfortunately, this is not the album a beginner wants to listen to.

I can appreciate how Miles Davis is different to Hugh Masekla or Duke Ellington. I can appreciate how THIS Miles Davis album is very different to 'A Kind of Blue' or 'Collector's Items'. But the issue for me is that, even though I can differentiate between these different styles and types, none of the different types stands out to me as better or more unique than another. I enjoyed the dreamy intro to 'In a Silent Way' and I enjoyed the tippy tapping of the drums in 'Shhh / Peaceful'. But I can't seem to find what makes jazz enthusiasts love the genre so much. (2.000)

Tenia solo dos canciones. Me aburrió y me enloqueció al mismo tiempo (lo escuché de fondo mientras trabajaba). No es lo mio evidentemente.

Ik voel mij hier echt perfect neutraal onder.

38 minutes squished into two songs. Okay jazz, I've heard better. I liked the start of ‘In a silent way’, and I wished it was its own song that I could listen to, but then it transitions to jazz again, I like the ending as well

I didn’t like this album

It mostly just felt like noodling for 40 minutes. There were a few moments of brilliance but a lot of it was over my head. It wasn't unpleasant but it didn't blow me away.

Not a really fan of jazz.

Lo puse y me quedé dormido, pero puede que no sea por la música a lo mejor por qué tenía sueño y estaba medio cansado. Acogedor.

Missed it

It’s not a bad album just not what I typically enjoy

I’m sure I would’ve have listened to this if it weren’t for this project. It was good to have on as background music while doing stuff in my house. I could see maybe having this on while, but it might be too loud/distracting for that. Rating: 2/5

Nice background music 2/5

J’suis désolé mais j’vais pas me taper 40min d’instru sachant que y’a seulement 2 sons

Johnny hates jazz. I don't like it much either, but I appreciated the underlying repetitive nature of this and not the improv jazz that just goes off on one with no rhythm. Early jazz trance music? If you squint a lot maybe.

I didn't really know I was supposed to feel or take away from this. It was happening, then it wasn't. I think the structure-less meandering doesn't really chime with me unfortunately. It felt like the different instruments were just playing whatever they felt like. I see this was the studio album before Bitches Brew which I didn't really like either, much prefer Kind of Blue and Round About Midnight from him

Empezó interesantísimo Me pasa parecido que con Stevie y su álbum. Son claramente muy talentosos, pero no me gusta casi el Jazz :( , o más que no me guste es que me aburre o no le encuentro el alma. Quizá porque disfruto mucho la percusión más dramática y lo teatral y eso no lo encuentro ahí. Es como música de fondo en un almuerzo. No tengo fundamentos técnicos para desmeritarlo, pero no es mi estilo. Al min 9:00 empieza a sonar algo interesante que me recordó como a champeta. nadie canta. Aunque creo que dicen que el jazz es la base de muchos géneros y entiendo eso. In a silent way empieza más dreamy pero luego se vuelve el fondo del buffet. jeje- Solo le pongo 2 y no 1 porque no quiero parecer iletrada ajja

vilicht liegts dra dass ich das während em schaffe glost han aber mir isch eif nd sehr viel blibe. isch eif so jazz halt vo dem an was ich mich erinnere chan.

I was enjoying the journey and then fell asleep (in a relaxed way not a bored way)

Slightly different than I was expecting, I thought it was going to be pure blues/soul jazz but it’s quite mystical, and kind of tells a story. The music may be from some film or tv program I’ve watched, I’m thinking of Louis Theroux documentary for some reason.

1/3. I just can’t get into this kind of jazz. Little to no dynamics, the same brush drums in the back the entire time, it just sounds like meandering to me. The inclusion of the Hammond is cool I guess, but not in the way they play it here. Just a bore.

10:30 in på B-sidan vaknar basen till liv och det händer något, ett groove. Det varar i knappt fem minuter och är det enda riktigt pigga ögonblicket på den här skivan. A-sidans Shhh/ Peaceful har i och för sig ett snyggt hihatbeat, men det blir aldrig mer än ett 19 minuter långt intro som aldrig kommer igång. Har man hört Bitches brew finns ingen direkt anledning att lyssna på denna sömniga förövning.

4/10

not my favourite jazz project

OK, nothing too great.

Sonically this was a stellar listen, but with a lot of instrumental records the replayability just isn’t there for me.

Dull but not unpleasant

Good quality, but not my cup off tea

Day768 - well i wasn’t expecting a two song album. if there’s a quota on the high-hat i believe we’ve reached it

I can't really handle how discordant the keys are through this album. I can't feel its rhythm and it feels like it's adding friction for the hell of it -- never do I feel any resolution with its presence. The album would be better off without it.

super good but.. very long and I like words in my songs

Obviously greatness but just doesn’t make a good album

Not really into such genre, so, good for some parties I guess

Sounds like a forty minutes of warm-up trumpet drills. Okay for background ambient music, but mid otherwise.

Don't love it.

A bit meandering for me sadly. Didn’t grab my attention much.

i know he is a genius in his field, but this music is not for me.

Not for me

I’m not a jazz fan so I only listened to the first three songs. I will say, if I were a jazz fan, this would be five stars. Given my somewhat dislike for jazz though, I cannot give it that rating.

Not my jam

I'm not really a jazz fan, so this doesn't exactly get tremendously high marks from me. However, I will say that I truly do appreciate the talent it takes to play like this. I have band experience, and, as someone who has heard bad horns and good horns, this was good. It just isn't for me, unfortunately. If you like jazz, however, you will LOVE this!

Too much jazz noodling for me.

Sigh. I wanted to love this, but Jazz is not so much my thing

Manche nennen es ein Meisterwerk. Ich nenne es: das längste Intro der Musikgeschichte – nur ohne den Song danach. In a Silent Way klingt, als hätte man eine Kreismusikschul-Combo mit einem Synthesizer allein im Studio gelassen und ihnen gesagt: „Spielt einfach irgendwas – wir nehmen alles.“ Was folgt, ist ein endloses, zielloses Geplänkel aus elektrifiziertem Gedudel, das sich für tiefgründig hält, aber in Wahrheit klingt wie der Soundtrack zu einem Aquarium-Bildschirmschoner. Miles Davis haucht sich durch seine Trompete, als würde er selbst nicht glauben, was da passiert, während die restliche Band zwischen „Ich hab den Einsatz verpasst“ und „Ich probier mal was“ pendelt. Natürlich wird das Ganze als „revolutionär“ gefeiert – vermutlich von denselben Leuten, die auch Waschmaschinen-Geräusche als Ambient-Kunst verkaufen. Zwei Sterne gibt’s für den Mut, Jazz so konsequent zu entkernen, dass selbst eingefleischte Fans sich fragen: „Ist das noch Musik oder schon Konzeptkunst mit Nebenwirkungen?“

Okay. It's a musically interesting album. Feels like Davis just took a few (very talented) studio musicians and improvised. There is an underlying consistent movement that is played throughout the album. But, the album is only 2 15ish minute songs. The underlying movement doesn't go anywhere. It's just the 1 for the entire song. Repeated. Over and over. The musicians improvise a few embellishments into repeated melodies. It's good, and shows off their individual talents, but there is little cohesion. It's not a masterpiece.

Вайб: будто посидела в кафе или посмотрела какой-то старинный фильм. Жанр: джаз. Поняла, что вообще не фанатка. Плюсы: можно слушать на фоне, не напрягает мозг. Минусы: долго, скучно. Оценка: 2.

Fine enough but I'm just not a fan of the 20 min ethereal jams

it’s okay kinda like annoying didn’t really strike me

Not his best by a long shot.

Background music. Cool to finally listen to someone I always see in the record stores. Not a record I'd buy

As Paul McCartney said, you can't both sing and play the trumpet at the same time I liked the first side/song/whatever more than the second, nice for on the background but that's about it.

Acabei por nao prestar muita atençao por ser tao instrumental, portanto a experiencia nao foi incrivel

not for me, but cool af 🔥

solid album, but just not really my thing

im sure this is a phenomenal jazz album, but 40 minutes of no lyrics is not for me.

2 songs, 38 minutes. It starts off okay, but after a while I start to lose my interest in the music. I think I would appreciate it more if I had seen it as a live performance and could watch the musicians jam away. This is just not my type of music, I guess.

OK for ambient music but not my type

More random noodling

Christ talk about pretentious, two 20 minute songs, fan of the drum in the first song but oh my god it is just the same shit with a trumpet taped on when Davis feels like it

“in a silent way” magari

I wanted to scream when i got this. Samw artist as the first one. This one was an easier listen, but still not my cup of tea.

Only 2 songs?? Hello? Definitely dissonant and odd. Feels like going through a worm hole at first.

It’s Miles Davis…

Better than Kind of Blues, liked the swing of it and this kind of jazz was nice.

not that interesting tbh

* fave song - in a silent way * the end of the song in a silent way was quite beautiful, but honestly i zoned out listening to the two songs. it got a little redundant at points. not really my thing but wasn’t the worst listen in the world.

I’m not a jazz fan and so I can’t judge this on any real level of expertise, but shockingly I couldn’t get into this. I quite like instrumentals, but nothing here grabbed me

- very repetitive elements (give me a headache) - also very long songs - usually love miles davis but this album isn‘t for me - ranking: 4/10, it gets tiring and annoying after a while

Was surprised to see that it was only two songs but it is over 30 minutes, so i guess it's an album. I like Jazz but I prefer something more lively. It was hard for me stay focused, especially cause it ranges around 16 mins per song.

I generally like jazz but I think I prefer the really old jazz or the more modern jazz and not really this in between stuff. I do like that he’s using electric elements but the way some parts are composed it is taking away from true melancholy while lacking bass and rhythm to lean into the more fun direction. It’s nice, calm background music but I can’t see myself actively listening to it.

Not the worst thing I’ve ever heard but still not my style. Never been able to really get behind jazz. I’m not saying it’s bad music, I just don’t find anything to grasp on to because there are no words.

I like jazz music but there wasn't much too this one, pleasant and added a certain vibe to my pasta cooking, but not much more than that. 49/100 Score edited 28/01/26

It's jazz. I suppose it could be interesting, but I just don't really care for it. Miles Davis is undoubtedly one of the greats and I can appreciate this from a technical perspective but I would never choose to put it on. Although was good background studying music.

A short list of things I'm not going to waste my time on: 1. 20 minute jazz songs. I'm sure it's great though..

If I liked jazz, I'm sure I would appreciate this album more but sadly, I didn't like it too much. I kept waiting for it to go somewhere and it just didn't, for me it was 40 minutes of nothing.

Really intimidating for me, didn’t really get along with it. Might revisit this but for now I think it will remain, as most jazz does for me, a bit of an uncrackable mystery. Is it just too ambient for my taste?

Very ambient

I never listen to jazz but it was alright. Not a huge fan and I don't think I'll litsen to it again.

This is not Miles' fault, I just really hate this kind of music.

Not my thing. 2/5

This is incoherent

Not bad compared to the other Miles albums. I much prefer this "electrified" approach. Some mellow jazzy guitar and drum supported Davis on lead trumpet fairly well. I can see this making the list for the outrage it caused the purists. Sort of like Dylan introducing electric guitar in folk or Lil Nas X rap singing country. I am still not fully in with the works from this Prince of Darkness and much prefer the one who works on the Sabbath. Like the effort here though on branching out and away for the boring, standard jazz so 2.15 stars.

I like other Mile Davis Songs/Albums, that's why I'm surprised I didn't enjoy this as much as I thought I would. The trumpet is lovely though and I like the bass line in the middle and end of In a silent way. Felt more like a 2/5 at first (tho it is more like a 2,5 but not quite a 3/5), but the trumpet and bass line, as well as the atmosphere at the end safed it to a 3. I might have a more positive view, when I revisit.

#765. Jazz 2/5: jazz

The musical prelude to the first two songs go on for...checks notes...the entire album.

Ok so Miles Davis and all. Still not something I would listen to on the regular. 2/5

Didn’t do much for me

In 2000 film Gladiator, Maximus asks the question: "Are you not entertained?" After listening to this album, my answer is "No." I'm not a huge jazz fan anyway, and I just found this aimless, meandering and pretty dull. I would probably enjoy watching this if it was at a gig, and the musicians were just jamming, but as an album, I can do without it.

Because of this album I had a dream where every time I tried to speak it sounded like a trumpet. My brain seemed to think this was a terrifying thought because it was set like a nightmare. Does this mean I have a deep set fear of being misunderstood? Do I have a lazy brain when it comes to creating nightmares? Or is this a recreation of a cartoon from my childhood that I feel like I can almost remember? I'm not sure. But because of it I don't feel like I can rate it super high, but I couldn't quite tell you why

Jazz music gives me nightmares

It was ok. Maybe ai wasn't in the mood to appreciate the jazz styling.... but it didn't really hit me, ya know?

Best Track - N/A

It seems like they bought 40 minutes in the studio. When finished said, just make it 2 songs. Fine background music but doesn’t do anything for me .

Undoubtedly an unreal album if you like jazz but it’s not for me

I guess this was decent; jazz is just not my thing….

There is a great quote attributed to Miles Davis. When asked for his thoughts on critics, he replied: "If I don't like what they're saying, I just get in my Ferrari and drive away." Excellent line. Very funny. So true. Two stars. I did not think much of this record. There is a fair bit of ambient noodling. Fine, very nice. There are textures to be enjoyed here for however long you can stand to just sit and look around a pleasant room. A bigger problem is that in the second half it invites you to pay attention by laying out a fairly conventional riff (the section called ‘It’s about that time’) which is, in my opinion, naff. I am not one to make bald accusations of that sort against one of the Great Men of Twentieth-Century Music but that riff is like something Des O’Connor would dander on stage to, except that version would swing and it wouldn’t take Des 10 minutes to do it. Shite. 1.5/5

I think I'm just not into jazz

Sorry but this is not your best work Mr Davis.

2 songs. 2 very long songs.

Jazz - Yet again, I recognize the cultural importance but man I cannot get into jazz

Ok music to listen to when eating a goose

Не люблю джаз, но этот интересный. Надо будет как-нибудь переслушать и вникнуть. Вряд ли сильно понравится, но внимания заслуживает точно

The album cover really made me think there was going to be more to this

Hitler seguro vetaba este disco, no hace falta ni conocer al artista para saber su tonalidad extrema monocromática de color de piel. En respecto al disco me. O yo soy muy básico para reconocer el buen blues/jazz pero me pareció muy básico, no me hizo querer mover el hombro que digamos.

I love miles earlier stuff with his quintet but I was not a fan of this one. It’s just music nothing particularly special about it to me.

This album was alright, pretty groovy but not my favorite

Wow, I didn’t like this at all.

Yeah im still no jazz guy

Nop, vraiment pas mon truc. Je note les albums avec mes goûts non pas en parlant de la musique réellement je vois bien qu’elle a des qualités mais je n’y reviendrais jamais et ça ne sera pas un manque dans ma vie loin de là

It's ok. Heard better from him. Didn't quite do it for me.

The ADHD boss battle of jazz. And I lost, abysmally. 🎺💀

I almost listened to this twice.

Es ist zwar einer der einflussreichsten Jazz - Musiker des 20. Jahrhunderts und ich möchte ihn hier auch nicht runter machen, aber ea ist einfach absolut nicht meins. Ich wüsste nicht zu welchem Anlass ich das hier nochmal hören wollen würde. Das erste Stück habe ich nach der hälfte abgebrochen und das 2. war weder entspannt genug um nebenbei zu lernen, noch um zu chillen. Sorry aber das ist nichts für mich. Aus respekt gebe ich noch 2 Sterne, da ich mir sicher bin das er gut spielt, es nur nicht meinen Geschmack trifft.

I recognize the instruments sound beautiful but honestly I couldn't listen to it completely. It is not the style of music I listen to daily but I appreciate the discovery.

I'm not really into Jazz

Too long and meandering for me….but that’s jazz I guess!

non mi convince la pronuncia

That's jazz baby. I don't really know how to talk about this kind of music. All I can say is that it was not really my cup of tea (a little too slow to hold my attention) but not actively bad

Different, 2 long songs stood out to me. Interesting, not the biggest jazz guy but it was good background music.

I’ve been really hit or miss with Jazz albums throughout this. My previous Miles Davis album, Birth of the Cool, I loved and gave it 5 stars. This one however I really struggled with. At some points I was really enjoying it, other times I hated it. Part of it might be listening to it in work. I will come back to it someday when I’ve listened to it in a more chilled setting.

I liked the first bit and got tired of it.

Well Yeah it's Jazz

Jazz: Strike one. Horn Jazz: Strike two. Instrumental music: Strike three.

Not my music.

I hate Bitches Brew and this sounded like Prelude to Bitches Brew. I hate Bitches Brew so much that I think I may have Bitches Brew-related PTSD, and so hearing how similar this was to Bitches Brew triggered me something fierce. I am sorry to those that like this kind of thing, but I very much do not.

Maybe I primed myself to dislike it, but what else am I supposed to feel when seeing 2 tracks (technically 3) at 38 minutes? I liked the fusion elements of some electric sounds layered in with the group, but for me, this style of Jazz featuring trumpet runs facing background repetition blurs together into a largely uninteresting 18-20 minute sludge.

cool but not really my thing 2/5

Jazz Fusion. Only two tracks for 38 mins of run time. A hugely influential and controversial album on the Jazz scene. Jazz is hit or miss for me. Some albums are cool. The rest aren't. I don't know what to do with this one though. An oddity.

A little bit too ambient for me. Respect the creativity at work here but probably won’t be back. It had a good vibe though 2.5

Lo siento, pero no conecto con el jazz.

I don’t understand jazz. I don’t know what makes it innovative, or controversial, but I know Miles Davis is an accomplished musician. To my ears this was just 38 minutes of noodling guitar and gently brushed percussion, and a bit of trumpet. It is audibly not just cobbled together nonsense, and parts of it reminded of the fade out of the Doors’ Riders on the Storm, but ultimately I just didn’t like it.

I know I should probably praise this to all high heaven……but jazz is not my thing.

This is the same to me as people that look at a couple of lines, squiggles and some paint thrown at a canvas and call it captivating art. I don't get it. I understand individually, anyone that can play an instrument even halfway decent, is an accomplishment unto itself. When those musicians get together and make free form jazz, it just sounds like noise. Personally, Miles oozed the cool and seemed like a polarizing figure. Musically though it just doesn't translate for me. I don't want to shit on it but it's just.......not good

Was hoping that I would enjoy this but I just didn't get it. Just sounded like endless formless noodling. Fairly pleasant to listen to but nothing I could really grab hold of. It illustrates my lack of connection perfectly that when the album ended and Tidal automatically ran onto some Jazz by John Coltrane, I didn't even realise the album had finished let alone that I now was listening to a completely different track and artist. Genuinely all sounded like nondescript Jazz noises to me.

Experimental, electronic Freeform pieces put together often linked with sizzle of hi-hat.

Self medicated beforehand which I think led to a little bit more enjoyment from my end. First song was challenging to follow along due to the lack of structure. Couldn't really find any particular element that really took the lead anywhere. It felt like a composition that didn't really have a backbone. Second song got better halfway through with more structure until it kinda faded away. Didn't hate, definitely didn't love. Definitely won't listen again. Decent 2/5

well what can i say? it’s a two track jazz album, i know i’m physically incapable of enjoying this and i was right. some ups and downs but by the minute 20 i was so bored that started cleaning my bathroom

I can appreciate the musicians behind this, the horn playing is amazing. But, I don't rent listening to this.

I get if you’re a jazz fan, this is great. For me, it was passable background music

As everyone else has said - reminds me of wait music.

It feels really kind of samey throughout the whole of the first 18 minute track. I guess there's some nice themes running throughout? Kind of? But there's really very little to grasp onto. The second track is so fucking boring. And why is the recording so bad? There's so much background hiss. I get that it's hardly a studio session, but still. This is a generous 2/5.

Originally not interested in listening to this record - not quite in the jazz mood. Then I decided to give it a quick listen. Got 2:40 minutes in and said no. Not my jam. at least for today.

Niet echt voor mij merk ik, word er een beetje zenuwachtig van. Maar snap wel heel goed dat mensen dit nice vinden

I would have preferred silence

Jazzy Elevator music Good if you wanna fall asleep +3 Very short listen time -1

Ahhhh, here we are again, another inclusion predicated on historical context I'm sure. Easy-listening jazz fusion album, perfect as a substrate for whatever might occupy you in the present moment. This greased the wheels nicely for me to get some coding done for my day job. Beyond that, I'll have to refer to the critics to understand why this stands out within the mid-century jazz milieu. I don't know what makes this exceptional. 5/10 -> 3/5. =========== I'm dropping my rating after reading the critic's take. It amounts to "you had to be a jazz stan 60 years ago, you had to listen to 'Kind of Blue' in a specific manner, and you had to understand Davis' bravery in experimentation". My response: this album's exceptionalism has since been lost to the sands of time, and the evolution of jazz itself. Do I disagree that Davis broke new ground? Absolutely not. Do I expect the albums on this list to speak for themselves? You bet your ass. Over half a century later, it sounds original, sure, but that's like, jazz, man! In retrospect, it just doesn't sound innovative. This album is fine. To a blind listener, it doesn't belong here. 2/5.

Still not a fan of this kind of jazz.

Horn jazz simply is not for me. Maybe I need to throw more high class dinner parties or something.

I found it hard to get into as not much of a tune. Maybe if I listened to it more to you'd start to recognise the tune, but most of it I just found myself glazing over. Second tune was better than first.

.

I feel like a plebeian for not getting into jazz more. These two tracks sound like I'm in a smoky bar sipping scotch.

Well, the clues in the title. Not great keeping music so quiet.

Jazz like this always just feels like background music to me. I forget it's even playing.

Great, more jazz. More people should put out 2 song albums, just not Jazz albums.

Just not my style

Not a fan of jazz, but this record had a few genuinely enjoyable moments

I'm not a fan of Jazz, found it quite overwhelming to be honest

I just can't get into jazz. It's fine in the background, but otherwise it's just irritating.

I always enjoy Miles Davis much more than many of the other jazz artists I get.

Jazz, sad second song

Meh