Arguably high 3s, but mostly liked the songs. Album itself is too long though (with slightly different versions of the same songs and some interview clips). Would try other songs by them
Another where the live-ness makes an actual impact
Maybe like 3.3. Not really my thing, but enjoyed more than expected -- could be right if looking for offbeat angst. Would listen to more by them
kind of fun, kind of annoying
Very chill, would def listen to more by him
3.7ish? Considered a 4, but not sure how much I'd actually listen to this (and I'm being harsher with ratings these days...)
Mostly enjoyed more than expected, some are a bit slow but overall fun
For some reason not what I was expecting, but they're v chill, weird quiet stuff with gentle acoustic guitar, etc. Rating lower just because 1 v long song was actively unpleasant to listen to (The Murder Mystery), but otherwise enjoyed if in the mood for that vibe
Bit discordant but in kind of fun way, dive bar vibes
3-3.5
Fine, but a bit slow and repetitive. Admittedly, didn’t closely listen to the lyrics
Enjoyed it but wasn’t my fave
3.5-maybe 4. It was fine, maybe would enjoy more on re-listen
Weird but cool, I quite enjoyed. Would def listen to more
The vocal parts got too weird for me, but I enjoyed other parts. I'd listen to other stuff by them
I didn't like every track, but enjoyed overall. Would listen to more by them, curious about later stuff.
so far only first 20 mins... not my thing, I think. Open to revisiting to see if I like it more sometime in the future, though.
Not unpleasant, but slower/sadder vibes than I prefer
I like REM, but I actually didn't think these particular songs were fantastic. Maybe a harsh rating...
Fun, maybe 4.5+? Good music to do something productive to. Would listen to more
More chill and less metal than had expected, but enjoyed. Would listen to more
Maybe high 3s, but need to listen again with more attention to lyrics for definitive
Weird but fun, listen to more by them
I think I had gotten him confused with Elton John, who (as of 4/4/26, maybe for no reason) I thought I would find annoying... but turns out I enjoy Billy's stuff!
Not my usual vibe, but pleasant listening
Prob 3.5? I don't especially love live albums and they're not what I generally listen to, but better than expected
Should listen to more of him!
Parts chill and enjoyable, others boring. Would try more if ever in the mood for slow, slightly psychedelic... but that's rarely my top choice
Fine, but kind of boring (adequate but slow)
Parts of it were sort of fun and I'd try more by them, but overall a bit meh
A lot of fun: upbeat, chill, mostly instrumental
Mostly pretty boring, generic pop-rock
Considered a 4, but probably a bit too slow/downer to really want to listen to. But did like it if ok with downer vibes, chill/slow and she has a nice voice, and worth trying again and listening more closely to lyrics
Maybe high 3s (3.5-3.8?), liked parts but overall slower than I usually go for. Chill though
Fun! Would listen to more by him
Had heard most of these, but I enjoy 'em
Not usually my fave kind of thing but actually quite enjoyed, and thought the live recording added to it
I already knew I liked them, but still a fun album. On the more folky side of their stuff (twangy guitar, harmonica, etc), fun
Considered a 4 because I enjoyed parts and think in the right mood I'd enjoy more, or possibly just other stuff by them, but parts of the album were not very enjoyable so I'm rating more harshly
4.5? Considered a 5. I liked the slight psychedelic + rock vibe, mostly fun songs.
I'd listen to the first half of the album again, but increasingly throughout it's more mixed-pleasantness instrumentals. Punk vibes in ways both fun and meh
Smooth jazzy pop, pleasant singing over elevator music but in a good way. I enjoyed it
It was fine, but found it a bit boring. Not bad though, could be good maybe when in the mood.
Weird but cool. Should definitely listen to again + other stuff by him. Hip hop-inflected instrumental stuff, with electronica flavor and some strange shit -- sort of meow wolf vibes
Nice and chill, some were slightly annoying but overall enjoyed
Need to re-listen to, but enjoyed
A few of the songs were fun, and a few were boring (especially 2 bonus tracks). Prob a 3.5-.75 depending on which I focus on
High 4s -- not my fave of theirs, but a lot of it is fun (and it's more funky vibes then other stuff, so if in mood for that it's a better choice)
I'd try them again, but need to be in the mood for Weird British Shit™
Thought they were fun! It's a lot of instrumental guitar solos and such, but fun chill vibe
Maybe more like 3.5-7, because parts were more eh. But overall chill, would be willing to try more
Could be up to a 4 or so, but even though I've liked other stuff from them, these weren't my fave
Maybe 4.5? Enjoyed, but felt a bit same-y by the end. Would listen to more by them, though
It’s Sinatra, you know what you’re getting! These maybe lean slower than some of his other stuff, though?
Some fun songs, would listen to more by them
This could be a 3 depending on the song... there were some fun ones, but a lot of them kind of drag and started sounding very repetetive.
Odd but fun, feels enjoyably old
Fine, but not really my thing
I enjoyed the 1st half, 2nd half got too boring (unless specifically looking for that vibe)
Maybe 3.5-4, but overall fine. Enjoyed at first but was a bit boring and repetitive by the end
Maybe like 4.5, not necessarily what I'd usually listen to but did enjoy it
Maybe 4.5+, depending on mood -- fun, enjoyed and would do more by them
Almost 5, but then the last few got too weird. High 4s though, bunch of bangers
4.something, would listen to more by her
Prob 4.4ish, only because a few of them were a bit slow. Overall good stuff
Enjoyed them, maybe like 4.5? Again, much more chill than I assumed they'd be
Grating, harsh and unpleasant... and yet the over-the-topness is pretty entertaining
Really 3.something I think, it's perfectly pleasant but not really my thing
Fun, not what I’m always in the mood for, but enjoyable when I am
Fun mix of old style and modern content
Fine for what it is... but what it is is same-y indie mope with a pretentious affect, didn't hate it as much as that sounds like, but I don't know when I'd choose it over something else
Fun short songs, but they kind of start to blend together
Maybe like 3.5, not bad but didn’t really stand out
4.something, fun mix of happy and melancholy
As I recall the last Talking Heads album was meh, even though I’ve heard and liked them before… and this was what I’d been hoping for from that one. Putting aside the unnecessary Outtake additions at the end and a bit of weirdness, quite enjoyed!
Would listen to more by the guy, didn't love every song but I enjoyed the general vibes